Penne alla vodka

A silky tomato and cream sauce with vodka. Miso and Parmigiano give the savouriness pancetta usually would, so there's no meat.

My own recipe.

In development: changed, not cooked as written yet48 amounts, times and temperatures are estimates, marked est. where they appear. Tap one to see why.
Serves
3 bowls
Takes
51 min, start to serving
Hands-on
about 35 min, plus 36 min with a pan or the oven to watch
Oven
Not needed

Not yet confirmed

No source or cook has confirmed these yet, so watch them as you cook.

  • How much vodka to simmer and how much to finish with: the next test (Simmer in the first vodka)
  • Shallot, as written: the 15 Nov cook used a small onion (Chop the shallots)

When to make each part

Latest start to servingCan start this much earlierHands-on, at a set timeHands-on, any time in this range

  • SauceStart by 51 min before serving, 24 min hands-on.
  • PastaStart by 34 min before serving, 4 min hands-on.
  • To finishJust before serving, 7 min hands-on.

This is one possible order. Each step only has to come after the steps it uses.

  1. Cook through to serving

    Sauce. Start at least 51 min before serving.

    1
    Sauce. 51 min before serving

    Chop the shallots

    Peel and very finely chop the 120g banana shallots.

    Aim: Chopped shallots.

    Not yet confirmed: Shallot, as written: the 15 Nov cook used a small onion.

    board4–6 minEstimate. About 2 banana shallots, very finely chopped.hands-on

    Pause point: it keeps 2 hours.Estimate. Prepared ingredients keep a couple of hours, covered.

  2. 2
    Sauce. 45 min before serving

    Sweat the shallot

    Heat the 15ml olive oil and 30g unsalted butter in a wide pan, add the chopped shallots and 1g fine salt, and cook gently without letting it colour.

    Aim: Soft, sweet shallot with no colour.

    Ready when the shallot is soft and translucent, with no colour.

    frying panhob, medium-low heat10–12 minEstimate. My judgement.check every few minutes
  3. 3
    Sauce. Any time from 51 min to 39 min before serving

    Grate the garlic

    Peel and finely grate the 3 garlic cloves.

    Aim: Grated garlic.

    board2–3 minEstimate. Three cloves on a fine grater.hands-on

    Pause point: it keeps 2 hours.Estimate. Prepared ingredients keep a couple of hours, covered.

  4. 4
    Sauce. Any time from 51 min to 36 min before serving

    Crush the tomatoes

    Crush the tomatoes with their juice in a bowl by hand. You need 400g tinned whole plum tomatoes: whole tins for three or six bowls, weighed out for four or five.

    Aim: Crushed tomatoes.

    board1–2 minEstimate. One tin by hand.hands-on

    Pause point: it keeps 2 hours.Estimate. Prepared ingredients keep a couple of hours, covered.

  5. 5
    Sauce. 33 min before serving

    Fry the purée

    Have ready: the grated garlic.

    Add the 1g chilli flakes and 80g double-concentrate tomato purée and spread the purée across the pan. Stir and scrape until it turns brick red and starts to catch. Add the grated garlic for the last minute only.

    Aim: Purée fried from bright red to brick red, just catching on the pan.

    Ready when the purée has turned from bright red to brick red and is starting to catch.

    frying panhob, medium heat4–5 minEstimate. My judgement.hands-on
    Watch Turn the heat down at the first dark spots; black purée tastes bitter. The garlic goes in for the last minute only, so it doesn't burn.
  6. Pasta. Start at least 34 min before serving.

    While the shallot sweats:

    6
    Pasta. Any time from 51 min to 34 min before serving

    Bring the pasta water to the boil

    Bring the 2.5l water to the boil in a large pan with the 25g fine salt.

    Aim: Salted water at a rolling boil.

    Ready when it's at a rolling boil.

    saucepanhob, high heat10–12 minEstimate. A typical hob for 2.5 litres.hands-off

    It can wait 30 minutes, at a simmer, lid on.Estimate. It only needs to be boiling when the pasta goes in.

    Note The pan needs room for the pasta on top of the water. For 5 or 6 bowls that means a stockpot, or two pans.
  7. While the water heats:

    7
    Sauce. 28 min before serving

    Simmer the tomatoes

    Have ready: the crushed tomatoes.

    Add the crushed tomatoes, the 1 dried bay leaf and a 5cm piece of Parmigiano rind, if you have one, and scrape up the bottom of the pan. Simmer gently, then fish out the bay and the rind and season with fine salt.

    Aim: A thick tomato base that no longer tastes tinny, seasoned now.

    Ready when it's thick and no longer tastes tinny.

    frying panhob, low heat12 minEstimate. My judgement.check every few minutes
    Taste Taste and fix it now, before the cream and cheese make it hard to tell what's off. Add salt if it needs it, and a pinch of sugar only if it tastes sour.
  8. 8
    Sauce. 16 min before serving

    Blend in the cream and miso

    Add the 90ml double cream and 15g white miso and blend smooth with a stick blender, tilting the pan so the sauce covers the blade, or in a tall jug if it's too shallow. For the silkiest sauce, push it through a fine sieve into a bowl, then pour it back into the pan.

    Aim: A smooth, silky sauce.

    Ready when it's smooth, with nothing left in the sieve but skins and seeds.

    frying panhob, low heat4–5 minEstimate. My estimate.hands-on

    It can wait 30 minutes, on the lowest heat, below a simmer.Estimate. A cream sauce holds warm for half an hour.

  9. While the tomatoes simmer:

    9
    Pasta. 17 min before serving

    Cook the pasta short

    Cook the 375g penne rigate for 2 minutes less than the packet says. Scoop out a jug of the water, then drain.

    Aim: Penne 2 minutes short of done.

    Ready when it still has a firm, chalky core when you bite one.

    saucepanhob, high heat9–11 minEstimate. 2 minutes short of a typical penne rigate's 11–13 minutes; go by the packet.check every few minutes

    It can wait 6 minutes, in the colander.Estimate. Drained pasta starts to stick after a few minutes; five or six is as long as it should wait.

  10. While the pasta cooks:

    10
    Sauce. 11 min before serving

    Simmer in the first vodka

    Bring the sauce to a gentle simmer, add the 30ml vodka and simmer until the sharp smell of alcohol has softened. Meanwhile, fill the bowls with hot water from the kettle to warm them.

    Aim: The sauce with the first vodka worked in.

    Ready when the sharp smell of alcohol has mostly gone.

    Not yet confirmed: How much vodka to simmer and how much to finish with: the next test.

    frying panhob, low heat5 minEstimate. With the 2 minutes' tossing, Kenji López-Alt's 7 minutes in the pan.check every few minutes
  11. To finish. Just before serving.

    11
    To finish. Any time from 51 min to 10 min before serving

    Grate the Parmigiano

    Finely grate the 40g Parmigiano Reggiano.

    Aim: Grated Parmigiano.

    board2–4 minEstimate. A small wedge on a fine grater.hands-on

    It can wait 2 hours.Estimate. Prepared ingredients keep a couple of hours, covered.

  12. 12
    Pasta. 6 min before serving

    Toss the pasta in the sauce

    Have ready: the pasta and the pasta water.

    Add the drained pasta and 100ml pasta water to the sauce and toss over a medium heat.

    Aim: Pasta coated in sauce, with sauce inside the tubes.

    Ready when the sauce clings to the pasta and fills the tubes.

    frying panhob, medium heat2 minEstimate. My judgement.hands-on
    Note For 5 or 6 bowls the wide pan may not hold it all. If so, tip the sauce into the emptied pasta pot and toss it there.
    If it goes wrong If the sauce pools in the pan, toss it longer over the heat until it clings.
  13. 13
    To finish. 4 min before serving

    Finish it off the heat

    Have ready: the grated Parmigiano and the pasta water.

    Take the pan off the heat. Stir in the grated Parmigiano, then the 15g unsalted butter, then the 15ml vodka. Toss for 30 seconds, loosening with more pasta water until glossy, then leave it for a minute.

    Aim: Glossy, just pourable, seasoned last.

    Ready when it's glossy and just pourable, and no oil beads at the edges.

    frying pan1 min, then 1 min waitingEstimate. My judgement.hands-on
    Taste Taste for salt last. The miso, rind, cheese and pasta water already bring plenty.
    If it goes wrong If it looks oily or grainy, take it off the heat, add a splash of hot pasta water and toss hard until it comes back together.
  14. 14
    To finish. 2 min before serving

    Serve in warm bowls

    Tip the water out of the bowls and dry them, then fill them. Top with the basil (a few leaves, optional), a little olive oil, black pepper and more Parmigiano at the table.

    Aim: Warm bowls of glossy penne, with cheese and basil.

    bowl2 minEstimate. My estimate.hands-on

Notes

My own version, built from Kenji López-Alt's vodka test, Cook's Illustrated's 2006 and 2024 write-ups and the USDA's alcohol-retention table. The vodka goes in twice: a simmered dose that works into the sauce for aroma and savouriness, and a small dose at the end that you taste as warmth. Both doses are a best guess from those sources, not yet tuned. If you can't taste the vodka, add a few more drops at the end; if it burns at the nose, cut the finish. The sauce base keeps 3 days in the fridge or can be frozen, as long as the vodka stays out of it until the day: reheated sauce loses its vodka. Parmigiano is made with calf rennet; for a strictly vegetarian version use Spenwood.